Siliadin vs france essay

But as Andrew Forrest put it several times, forms of slavery exist in almost every country of the world, even in unexpected ones. In some national news we can refer to cases related to slavery occurring in private houses in which most likely there is a foreign person with economic difficulties assisting an elderly person and in which that person at work lives as a prisoner and can no longer enjoy their basic human rights. Many have been the cases reported in different parts of Europe such as the one that concerned hundreds of Romanian workers who were transported to Germany and were forced to work in strawberry fields under degrading conditions; the one about an asparagus farm in the Netherlands, in which Romanian, Polish and Portuguese work was performed under conditions that were reminiscent more of a form of slavery than a modern business. Many countries around the world have taken this provision into account, deciding to recognize forced labor as a severe human rights breach in their legislation.

Siliadin vs france essay

Nicholas Villalta How successful has the United Nations been in eradicating all forms of slavery and the slave trade around the world today? Villalta University of Reading School of Law 1 Slavery describes the condition when someone exercises ownership over someone else.

The practice of slavery goes back through history, with contention as to its original start date. Slavery has since become a very antagonistic topic and one, which seems today to have finally won over the legislatures of the world.

However, sadly it is not all good news. Today an estimated million people worldwide are said to be subject to contemporary forms of slavery1, and modern day slavery is said to be the third most Siliadin vs france essay business for organised crime2, behind only drugs and arms, and also the fastest growing one.

The establishment of the United Nations3 in and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights have helped tackle slavery, but just how successful has it been? The UN has been plagued with a magnitude of problems to date, and all have resulted in a plethora of issues which need to be resolved before being able to claim victory.

Through this essay I will be outlining the definition of slavery, addressing the status of the legislation, assessing the success of the UN in tackling slavery, whilst suggesting my own ideas for improvement as well as addressing related issues and the role of non-state actors.

Additionally there are some issues such as poverty, which are said to be linked to the eradication of slavery which should be tackled in collaboration with the issue, but which the UN is not addressing sufficiently.


I will finally assess the capability of the UN to tackle slavery, as it can only do so much before actions of others become necessary. A situation of trafficking, debt bondage, bonded labour, or forced labour will be identifiable as slavery only if it has involved, as required by the Convention…[the requisite elements of control over ownership] 8.

This demonstrates that it is still crucial to consider the core element when identifying slavery. Despite the core element of slavery not changing, the idea of what can constitute slavery has, and so as to avoid dwindling into irrelevance, numerous international instruments have been enacted which reflect the prohibition of the new idea of exploitation of persons.

Today, we have numerous instruments which prohibit the practice of slavery. Firstly, we have the Slavery Convention which prohibits slavery and the slave trade, secondly, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights article 4 and the International Convention on Civil and Political Rights article 8 which abolish slavery and servitude, thirdly, the UN Committee on Slavery Cmnd which abolished slave-like practices of debt bondage, serfdom, persons sold into marriage, and sham adoption of children, fourthly, the ICCPR article 8 3 which prohibits forced or compulsory labour and finally, the Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, 5 Slavery Convention ofArt 1.

Quagmire or Firm Ground? The reason for the enactment of these instruments is that the initial definition of slavery was found to exclude practices which are slave-like, and so the definition was extended to include conditions as mentioned above. This vast plethora of protection from slavery shows how far reaching the concept is in the world, and also how confusing it can be.

Being a customary norm also means that States do not have to ratify a multilateral treaty to be bound by the norm11; this places the norm in a high and prominent position on the international stage We can see the effect that this has had by looking at the impact it had on the ruling of the Filartiga v Pena-Irala case13 which means it is now possible for victims to punish non-natives and natives alike inclusive of state officials, private actors and transnational companies who violate the law of nations, under public international law.

Hounga v Allen & Anor [2014] UKSC 47

From this we adduce that there is no needs for a strict legal right of ownership, so long as the victim is still in the same situation. Additionally, consent has been held to be irrelevant in slavery, whether or not the victim consented. This emphasises the need and importance of having a proper definition.

From my interpretation, the definition of what constitutes slavery is that of a position of control and ownership, by a person, over another, and this is supplemented by all the different forms of slave-like practices as seen from the above treaties.


But additionally, slavery is a peremptory norm of international law, a norm that transcends all international borders and burdens all governments, and it does this in all the shapes and forms that it takes in todays context.

The United Nations — be all and end all, or political fantasy? The UN is comprised of a committee of nations, whose actions are authorised by the Member States, and its issues are dealt with thematically dependent on the agenda of these States.

It is important to bear in mind the idea of it being a committee of nations, as when analysing the successes or failures of the UN, it must be remembered that it is limited to what its members allow it to do and therefore the analysis is really of the success or failure of the nation States themselves.

The reason behind this is simple, States reluctance to give up their own sovereignty to another body. This is an important aspect of the UN, as the UN can only act upon the powers granted by Nation States, powers which they themselves do not want to give up. How does this effect the eradication of slavery?

Whilst all Nation States are committed, and indeed bound, to eradicating slavery, they balance surrendering enough sovereignty to the UN to allow it to function with, withholding enough for their satisfaction. If then, neither the UN nor the Nation State due to slavery having to be tackled globally is in a position to eradicate slavery wholly, then neither can.Syracuse University in Strasbourg HUMAN RIGHTS IN EUROPE – A COMPARATIVE OVERVIEW Final exam (open book essay/s): 40 % Siliadin v.

France The Refugee (Geneva) Convention ECHR, Chahal v. UK ECHR, D v. UK ECHR, Hirsi Jamaa and Others v. Italy. Readbag users suggest that Journal Watch, Fourth Quarter , A to I is worth reading.

Siliadin vs france essay

The file contains 50 page(s) and is free to view, download or print. 2 The applicant argued that the harassment and discrimination she would face for wearing the veil would amount to degrading treatment in violation of article 3 and a violation of article Human trafficking is the trade of humans for the purpose of forced labour, sexual slavery, or commercial sexual exploitation for the trafficker or others.

Siliadin v. France, judgment of 26 July , and Rantsev v.

Siliadin vs france essay

Cyprus and Russia, judgment of 7 January 2 The applicant argued that the harassment and discrimination she would face for wearing the veil would amount to degrading treatment in violation of article 3 and a violation of article Siliadin v France.

Van Ness, Daniel. Proposed UN basic principles on restorative justice In this essay, Van Ness provides a historical overview of a Documents Similar To Van Ness Essay. Ent s3 Mccrimmon. Uploaded by. Pooja Meena. ODR AND RESTORATIVE JUSTICE ONLINE: CLARIFYING CONCEPTS DUE TO ITS LEGAL IMPLICATIONS.

Uploaded by.

“Refugees” Defined - bole debate & speech academy